Secret Santa✦ Magic & Secret ✦

Secret Santa rules and fun twists

There are only a handful of real Secret Santa rules, but agreeing them up front prevents almost every awkward moment. Once the basics are sorted, a twist can make the whole thing far more memorable.

The basic rules

  1. Everyone gives one present and receives one. Nobody draws themselves.
  2. Stick to the budget. Not much under, definitely not over.
  3. Keep it secret. Don’t tell anyone who you drew, at least until the exchange.
  4. Respect the date. Bring (or post) your present in time.
  5. Follow the group’s notes, such as “no food”, “nothing alcoholic” or “handmade only”.
  6. Keep it kind. Jokes are fine; gifts that embarrass someone aren’t.

Draw names with your rules written into the draw

🎁 Draw names for free

House rules worth deciding

10 twists to make it more fun

1. Themed Secret Santa

Everything must fit a theme: red things, something from a charity shop, something starting with the recipient’s initial, or “a gift from your hometown”.

2. Funny gifts only

The sillier the better, usually with a lower budget. Works brilliantly with friends, less so with new colleagues.

3. Handmade Secret Santa

No shop-bought presents: bake, knit, draw, print, build. Set the budget for materials only.

4. Something to use, read and wear

Three small items instead of one, within the same total budget.

5. Guess the giver

At the exchange, each person guesses who their Santa was before the reveal. Keep score for extra fun.

6. Clue trail

The giver leaves three clues about their identity in the week before the exchange (left on a desk, or sent anonymously).

7. White elephant swap

Everyone brings one wrapped gift and players can “steal” opened gifts. It doesn’t need a name draw. Full rules in our white elephant guide.

8. Reverse Secret Santa

Each person wraps something they’d love to receive, then presents are swapped at random.

9. Poem or riddle

Every present comes with a short rhyme about the recipient. Expect groans and laughter.

10. Charity Santa

Instead of a present, each person donates the budget to a cause their recipient cares about and writes them a card explaining why.

Where to write the rules

When you create the draw, use the Rules / notes field. Everyone sees it when they reveal who they got, so nobody can say they didn’t know.

Frequently asked questions

Do you have to reveal who your Secret Santa was?

It’s up to the group. Some groups reveal at the exchange, others keep it secret forever.

What if someone goes over budget?

Write the budget into the draw and remind people a week before. Most overspending is simply forgetting the limit.

Are gift cards allowed in Secret Santa?

Only if your group agrees. Many groups ban them because the fun is in choosing something personal.